Showing posts with label adoption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adoption. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 1, 2007

Review of BEST BEST COLORS

Hoffman, Eric and Celeste Henriquez (Ill.). 1999. BEST BEST COLORS. St. Paul, MN : Redleaf Press. ISBN 9-7818-8483-469-1

PLOT SUMMARY
Nate struggles to decide which color is his “best, best.” Along the way, he chooses a favorite mamma—first one, then the other, then neither. When he cannot decide who his best friend is, he wonders, “Do I have to pick just one?” Finally, after making a rainbow flag with his mammas, Nate realizes he doesn’t have to choose just one. They can all be his “best, best.”

CRITICAL ANALYSIS (INCLUDING CULTURAL MARKERS)
BEST BEST COLORS is a story which illustrates a typical conundrum for young children: the exclusivity of choosing favorites. As Nate capriciously chooses favorites throughout the story, he is surrounded by a diverse assortment of family and friends. Among the diversities addressed are ethnicity, family structure, and abilities. This diversity is primarily conveyed through the illustrations rather than overtly discussed in the story.

The ethnicities represented in BEST BEST COLORS are African-American, Anglo, Asian-American, and Hispanic. Three of these cultures are represented within the family of the main character, Nate. Nate and Mamma Laura are black, Mamma Jean is Anglo, and Nate’s sister is Asian-American. While none of these ethnicities are discussed in the text, Henriquez uses coloration and facial features to portray non-stereotypical examples of each. Another important facet of this book’s multicultural appeal is the fact that it is bilingual. In fact, the entire series of which it is a part, “Anti-Bias Books for Kids,” has been translated into Spanish.

Hoffman also addresses diversity in family structure. This diversity is alluded to in an unobtrusive manner. Nate refers to his mammas, but not the fact that he has two mammas. Nor is it mentioned that other families might not be the same. The only overt textual reference to gay and lesbian culture is when his mammas are showing Nate a rainbow flag, “Look what we got for the Pride Parade.” Even this reference to gay culture could be overlooked by young readers or older readers who are not well-informed. Another example of diversity in family structure is Nate’s sister, who is most likely adopted. She is seen but not heard. Indeed, the reader is aware of her existence solely because of the illustrations.

Finally, differently-abled diversity is included in BEST BEST COLORS. One of Nate’s friends, Mandy, uses a wheelchair. Again, this representation of a parallel culture is known only because of the illustrations. No mention of her handicap is made in the text. Mandy’s use of a wheelchair is not so much a character development tool, rather it is a detail in the illustrations.

Rather than promote diversity, Eric Hoffman’s primary thrust appears to be helping readers deal with the issue of choosing exclusive favorites. On the other hand, Henriquez’ primary intention is to imbue the story with diversity and multiculturalism. Being part of the “Anti-Bias Books for Kids” series is most likely the rationale behind the plethora of cultures represented in BEST BEST COLORS. However, it is a bit heavy handed. Just as a book about any ethnicity can be overwhelmed by too many cultural references, so too may be a book about diversity and tolerance in general.

REVIEW EXCERPTS
“The engaging story is enhanced by lively full-page illustrations depicting a multicultural cast of interesting characters” (Day, p. 5).
“A ‘Note to Parents, Teachers, and other Caregivers’ at the end of each book suggests follow-up activities and discussion topics. Overall, these purposeful titles meant to encourage readers to think about these issues fall short in the execution of their mission. (Library Journal, 1999)*

*Note: The author of this review, Kristina Aaronson of Bethel Elementary School Library in Vermont, includes examples from three of the four titles in this review of the Anti-Bias Books for Kids series. BEST BEST COLORS is not mentioned.

Day, Frances Ann. 2000. Lesbian and gay voices: An annotated bibliography and guide to literature for children and young adults. Westport, CN : Greenwood Press.

Library Journal review obtained from Amazon.com and accessed at: http://www.amazon.com

CONNECTIONS
Other books in the Anti-Bias Books for Kids series:
PLAY LADY, ISBN 978-1884834615
NO FAIR TO TIGERS, ISBN 978-1884834622
HEROINES AND HEROES, ISBN 978-1884834684

Related website:
A WORLD OF DIFFERENCE® Institute

Thursday, July 26, 2007

Review of ALLISON

Say, Allen. 1997. ALLISON. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. ISBN 9-780329-39549-0

PLOT SUMMARY
Allison and her doll, Mei Mei, live happily with her mother and father. One day, Allison notices she doesn’t look like her parents. When she realizes she’s been adopted, she bitterly focuses on the fact that her “real” parents didn’t want her and gave her away. As she broods and acts out, Allison struggles to deal with her anger. Finally, Allison is able to work through her feelings by taking a stray cat into their family.

CRITICAL ANALYSIS (INCLUDING CULTURAL MARKERS)
Allen Say tells an emotional story of a little girl dealing with her family. Through the use of plot, characterization (including voice), language, and illustrations, ALLISON conveys a realistic picture of how a child dealing with adoption might feel.

The story opens with Allison receiving a dress from her grandmother. Her parents “ooh” and “aah” over how pretty she looks wearing her kimono. The mother’s use of the term kimono is Allison’s first clue that there is something different about her. She realizes for the first time how differently she looks from her parents. The inevitable conversation takes place between the child and her adoptive parents, “You’re not my Mommy and Daddy?” she asks. To which her parents reply, “of course we are….” This exchange only serves to deepen Allison’s dismay. Her sadness comes to a climax when she realizes Allison is not her ‘real’ name. This plot shows a realistic journey of a young girl dealing with her identity.

The characters in ALLISON are neither homogenous nor stereotypical. The adoptive parents are hurt by Allison’s outbursts, yet they are patient with their daughter. Allison’s school mates, representing many different ethnicities, reflect varied skin tones, body shapes, and hair styles. Allison, who is adopted from an unspecified Asian country, also exhibits a non-stereotypical view of her ethnicity. Except for the time she is trying on her new kimono, Allison wears typical clothing for an American child.

Say’s use of voice further contributes to the characters’ believability. Allison’s question, “Where did Mei Mei come from?” accurately depicts a child’s tendency to project questions about themselves onto dolls or animals. Later, when Allison is acting out against her mother, she ruins her dolls. Rather than fuss at Allison, the mother laments, “Oh, no, poor [dolly]! I’ve had him since I was a little girl.” This type of response reveals a believable interaction between a mother and daughter which is full of anger and pain yet grounded in love.

The illustrations and use of Japanese words provide a fullness to ALLISON. Say’s ability to capture realization, anger, pain, and defiance in his characters’ faces is outstanding. At the story’s most painful moments, Say uses dark somber colors. At the end, Allison’s breakthrough with the stray cat is accompanied by bright sunlight and pastel background colors. Say tops off the cultural allusion by including words such as Mei Mei (the doll’s name), kimono, and obi.

ALLISON is a touching story about a family dealing with adoption. This realistically portrayed situation is conveyed through the adept use of literary tools and a sensitive yet authentic approach to ethnic diversity.

REVIEW EXCERPTS
“Her adoption of a stray cat brings about a happy ending that seems less earned than bibliotherapeutic. The large, sober paintings are often heavy, and the bookmaking, though handsome, is too big and elegant for the family drama it is meant to support.” (Horn Book)
“Cleverly, Say uses a stray cat that Allison wants to adopt to help her come to terms with her anger as she realizes everyone needs a family. A subtle, sensitive probing of interracial adoption, this exquisitely illustrated story will encourage thoughtful adult-child dialogue on a potentially difficult issue.” (Publishers Weekly)
“Say masterfully captures Allison's expressions: She is surprised, wounded, sullen, hurt and hurtful, and finally reassured. He addresses the dark side of an adoptive child's feelings carefully, and while the resolution is a bit convenient (and may require interpretation for younger children), it still carries truth.” (Kirkus Review)

Reviews obtained from Follett Library Resources and accessed at:
http://www.flr.follett.com

CONNECTIONS
Other books by Allen Say:
THE BICYCLE MAN, ISBN 978-0-395-32254-3
EL CHINO, ISBN 978-0-395-52023-9
EMMA’S RUG, ISBN 978-0-395-74294-5

Other books about adoption:
Lewis, Rose A. 2000. I LOVE YOU LIKE CRAZY CAKES. New York, NY : Little, Brown. ISBN 978-1-59990-017-9
Young, Ed. 2006. MY MEI MEI. New York, NY : Philomel Books. ISBN 978-0-395-74294-5
Friedrich, Molly. 2004. YOU’RE NOT MY REAL MOTHER! New York, NY : Little, Brown. ISBN 978-0-316-60553-3

Related website:
http://www.houghtonmifflinbooks.com/authors/allensay/